The Dish

The Marshmallow Treats Contemplation

This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my Affiliates Disclosure.

Did you know that the recipe for marshmallow treats on the back of the box of Rice Krispies is different today from years back?  I was so surprised when I bought a box of Rice Krispies today and saw that the recipe on the back of the box was slightly different than the one I know.  Even though it is different, in fact the recipe has changed very little since its debut in 1939.

A 1939 Debut

1939?  Oh wow… I hate to go off subject here, but in many ways 1939 is arguably the very best year for movie making in Hollywood. Some of the greatest movies ever made were released in 1939 and nominated for Best Picture for that year:  Gone with the Wind, The Wizard of Oz, Goodbye Mr. Chips, Mr. Smith Goes to Washington, Stagecoach, Dark Victory, Ninotchka, Of Mice and Men, Love Affair, and Wuthering Heights.  Wow!  Sorry… there went that squirrel again!  Time to get back on topic!

In this print ad, which I believe is from 1939, the original ingredients listed are butter, marshmallows, vanilla extract, and Kellogg’s Rice Krispies.  The name of this new sensation is “Crispy Candy – Rice Krispies Marshmallow Squares”.

9-minute "crispy candy" Ad 1939


I’m not sure what year this next particular print appeared, but I’m guessing it is from the late 1940’s since the box lettering is now black and Snap, Crackle, and Pop are in color and have the rounded ears.  Here you can see that butter and margarine are listed as interchangeable in the recipe.

Quick Treat Ad - 1940's

Making Treats in College

The very first time I made Rice Krispies Treats was about 40 years ago and I still remember the original recipe shown to me by a college friend.   I remember it because it only used a half a stick of Parkay margarine and you had to count (yes!… count!!) the number of marshmallows for the right proportions of buttery marshmallow goo to Rice Krispies Cereal.  Even though I grew up in a frugal household, my parents never bought margarine.  They only bought butter.  So, for me, it was a terrible wasteful idea of buying a whole pound of margarine for a recipe that only used about 1/8th of the package.  But, my friend was very insistent that I not substitute butter for the Parkay.  As it turns out margarine and butter are interchangeable for this particular recipe, since butter was the original ingredient.

In case you are wondering… here are the ingredients my college friend gave me:

  • 4 Tablespoons Parkay Margarine
  • 40 Marshmallows
  • 6 Cups Rice Krispies Cereal

…and here is that particular recipe, which appeared in a print ad:

Rice Krispes Treats - Recipe from College Days

There is no vanilla in this particular version and PARKAY margarine is prominently mentioned.  Also, the name is now “Marshmallow Treats” and the name is tradmarked!

Today, there are a lot of recipes, names, and versions for “Cereal Marshmallow Treats”.  Compared to the original recipe, some have more butter, some have less.  Some versions have the original vanilla extract… and still others add coloring, candies, nuts, coconut, chocolate, and/or other cereals like Cocoa Krispies or Fruit Loops.  Needless to say, they are all simple to make and absolutely yummy!

As for the recipe currently on the back of  the box of Kellogg’s Rice Krispies, it contains one tablespoon less of butter/margarine and has no vanilla.  Hmmmmm…. and then there is this:

A Starbuck’s Version

I noticed about 2 weeks ago that Starbuck’s is selling a “Marshmallow Dream Bar”.  I haven’t tried one.  But it looked like regular Marshmallow Rice Krispies Treats with miniature marshmallows stirred in to give chunks of marshmallow running through the bar.  As a matter of fact, it looked like my recipe, only I use the miniature pastel colored “fun” marshmallows for my stir-in.  Oh…and note the name, “Marshmallow Dream Bar”.  No doubt that might be to avoid an issue with the fact that “Marshmallow Treats” is trademarked.

The Contemplation Summary

You might be wondering where I’m going with this long contemplation of the Marshmallow Treat and it is this:  

My college friend just had to have Parkay in her treats and some people swear the vanilla extract is essential.  My thoughts are… if you like a recipe on the back of a package, take a photo of it, cut it out, or write it down.  Because nothing stays the same forever.  Tastes and economies will change over time and manufacturers will change branding, recipes, and recipe names.

Overall Marshmallow Treats  have had these changes: the vanilla extract has been removed completely from the original recipe and the butter/margarine has been reduced to a mere 3 tablespoons from the original 4… and I ask why?  I would assume the vanilla extract was omitted due to cost.  When marshmallows are already vanilla flavored and budgets are tight, I can see this change would make sense.  As for the reduction of butter/margarine, I can only guess it is also for ecomony. 

But, this reduction also makes a treat that not as soft and can have a sturdy and sometimes hard texture.  That harder texture is not necessarily a bad thing.  It is great for holding it’s shape.  Freshly cut squares of treats made with less butter stack beautifully… and you probably have seen it used on cooking shows for edible sculptures.

Well… I think this contemplation has gone on long enough and it’s time to get cooking!  So, at long last… 

Here is Today’s Recipe!

Clear Pink Bunny Egg and Tart Pan Filled with Springtime Marshmallow Treats

Today, I wanted to do something delicious and fun with Marshmallow Treats!  So, I’m made them with a little extra butter to make the treats very pliable and chewy.  Also, since I love all things vanilla, the vanilla extract is in!  My favorite stir-in is the miniature pastel marshmallows, which look so pretty for Spring.

Oblong Tart Pan Filled with Springtime Marshmallow Treats

 After, making the treat mixture, it is placed inside buttered hollow plastic eggs, the kind that can be filled for egg hunts.  However, the treats are so very pretty, I couldn’t resist putting some in a tart pan to be cut later! 

Springtime Marshmallow Treat in Easter Egg Mold

Today’s recipe is:  Springtime Marshmallow Treats